COMMUTING TO NYC FROM SHORT HILLS, NJ : WHAT TO KNOW

Thinking about living in Short Hills and commuting into Manhattan? You want a routine that’s predictable, efficient, and worth the cost. The good news: Short Hills offers some of the best commuting options in New Jersey, including a direct Midtown train, express buses, and easy access to major highways. This guide breaks down how each route works, what to expect for time and cost, and tips to help you choose the commute that fits your lifestyle. Let’s dive in.

WHY SHORT HILLS WORKS FOR COMMUTERS

Short Hills sits in a prime location in Essex County, offering direct rail service into Penn Station, quick access to I-78, and multiple bus routes into Manhattan. The town is known for its quiet residential streets, top-rated schools, and convenient proximity to NYC making it one of the most desirable commuter suburbs.

Unlike many New Jersey towns, Short Hills has its own NJ Transit station right in the community, which makes rail commuting extremely popular. Drivers also appreciate having multiple highway options, while hybrid commuters can mix train, bus, and rideshare depending on their schedule.

If you work in the city full-time or follow a hybrid pattern, Short Hills gives you real flexibility.

YOUR MAIN COMMUTE OPTIONS

TRAIN TO PENN STATION (NJ TRANSIT – MORRIS & ESSEX LINE)

The Midtown Direct train is the most popular choice for Short Hills residents. Trains run frequently during peak hours.

Typical ride time:

• About 35–45 minutes to Penn Station (direct service).

Check up-to-date schedules and fares on the NJ Transit Morris & Essex Line.

Pros:

• Fastest and most predictable commute.

• No parking or tolls in Manhattan.

• Great for Midtown workers and anyone wanting reliability.

Tradeoff: You’ll want a parking permit or walking distance to the station. Morning rush trains can get crowded.

DRIVING INTO MANHATTAN

Driving gives you full flexibility and is a popular option for those with irregular work hours. From Short Hills, you typically use:

• I-78 East → Holland Tunnel

• Route 24 → I-78 → Lincoln Tunnel

Typical travel time:

• Off-peak: 35–50 minutes

• Peak hours: 60–90+ minutes, depending on tunnel traffic

You’ll pay tolls, and Manhattan parking can add significant cost unless your employer covers it.

Pros:

• Full door-to-door control.

• Works great for early or late meetings.

• Best for office locations outside Midtown.

Tradeoff:
Traffic and tolls can add up quickly.

EXPRESS BUS TO MANHATTAN

Bus routes serving Millburn/Short Hills connect to Midtown and downtown Manhattan. Times vary based on traffic.

Typical ride time:

• About 45–75+ minutes, depending on tunnel delays and time of day.

Check NJ Transit bus schedules and fares for exact routes.

Pros:

• No Manhattan parking fees.

• You can read, relax, or work during the ride.

Tradeoff:
Buses share tunnel traffic, so reliability can fluctuate during peak hours.

TRAIN + SUBWAY / RIDESHARE MIX

Some commuters prefer combining NJ Transit with the subway, PATH, or rideshare for specific destinations — especially if working downtown or on the East Side.

Pros:

• Flexible for changing locations.

• Useful for hybrid schedules.

Tradeoff:
More transfers, but often faster than driving in heavy traffic.

MIX AND MATCH AS NEEDED

One of the advantages of Short Hills is having multiple solid options. You can take the train on busy days, drive when you need flexibility, and use rideshare or buses for off-peak trips.

Many Short Hills commuters use a hybrid strategy:

• Train on Monday/Tuesday

• Drive on days with late meetings

• Bus or rideshare when weather impacts rail schedules

Build a flexible plan that matches your work style.

AT-A-GLANCE COMPARISON

PARKING & ACCESS IN SHORT HILLS

Parking near the Short Hills NJ Transit station requires a permit, and spots may be limited during peak seasons. Millburn Township provides permit information and updates on availability.

If you prefer not to park at the station:

• Consider walking or biking if you’re nearby

• Arrange drop-offs or rideshare

• Look for private commuter parking options in surrounding areas

Always double-check local regulations before parking in residential zones.

TIME AND COST PLANNING

Peak windows:

• 6:30–9:30 AM and 4–7 PM see the heaviest train and tunnel congestion.

Cost factors to compare:

• Tunnel tolls

• Manhattan parking fees

• NJ Transit monthly pass

• Bus fares

• Rideshare or local parking permits

Policy watch: NYC congestion pricing may impact certain vehicle trips into Manhattan. Follow updates on the MTA congestion pricing project if driving into central zones is part of your routine.

If you work hybrid, calculate your monthly costs based on real commuting days, many Short Hills residents find the train pass or express bus extremely cost-effective for 2–3 office days per week.

LOCAL TIPS TO TEST BEFORE YOU BUY

Run a test commute:
Take your exact route at your typical work hours.

Try multiple options:

• Do a Midtown Direct train one day

• Drive through the Holland or Lincoln Tunnel another

• Test a bus route during peak time

Price out your routine:
Use official sources like NJ Transit schedules and fare pages for accuracy.

Ask about commuter benefits:
Many NYC employers offer pre-tax transit and parking benefits, lowering your monthly costs.

Have a backup plan:
Weather, tunnel delays, or mechanical issues happen — knowing your second option ensures a stress-free routine.

CHOOSING YOUR BEST FIT

• Choose the train if you want speed, predictability, and Midtown access.

• Choose driving if you need flexibility or work outside central Manhattan.

• Choose the bus if you want a cost-effective option without parking fees.

• Choose a mix for hybrid work schedules.

Short Hills offers one of the most commuter-friendly setups in New Jersey. With direct rail service, flexible transit choices, and strategic highway access, you can tailor your commute to your exact work pattern.

Considering a move to Short Hills or exploring homes that match your NYC commute?

I can help you compare neighborhoods, schools, and transit options so your move supports both your lifestyle and your work routine. Let’s connect! Katherine Barrera (732) 423-3062